Thursday, March 21, 2019
About Us
Please enter your email here, we would like to keep you informed.
Connect With Us - Facebook RSS
<March 2019>
Liberty In The News
Liberty Events
Conference Proceedings
Development is the Key
Economic Freedom
Education for Life
Freedom of Expression
Freedom to Trade
Globalization for the Good
Health is Wealth
Intellectual Property Rights
International Relations
Liberty is Security
Limited Government
Principles of Politics
Population - the ultimate resource
Property Rights
Regulatory Affairs
Rule of Law
Tax Freedom
Facts & Figures
 Education for Life
More than just a slap on the wrist
Hindustan Times, India Saturday, June 19, 2010

Vir Sanghvi
Corporal punishment is a barbaric practice. Yet, it flourishes in India. It is partly because school authorities think they can get away with anything they do to our children. The Government has artificially restricted the supply of schools serving the middle class, writes Vir Sanghvi in Hindustan Times.

There are many arguments against corporal punishment but the essence of the issue can be encapsulated in a single question: would you let a stranger assault your child?

You could argue that a school teacher is not a stranger but such a claim would be bogus. The people who teach our children remain strangers to most of us. We may hear about them from our kids and perhaps meet them a couple of times each term, but we know nothing about them. We do not know what kind of people they are – sadists, perverts, maniacs or whatever — and we do not know enough about them to judge whether they are capable of awarding punishment fairly.

We grant them authority over our children largely because we have no choice. In most Indian cities and towns, we can get our children into schools of our choice with the greatest difficulty. Once principals admit our children, they act as though they have done us favours or bestowed some great honour upon us. The balance of power is tilted toward the school, its teachers and its administrators. We are lucky to have got our kids in and are never allowed to forget that.

This fundamental imbalance in the relationship between schools and parents — caused largely by the excess of demand for school places over supply — is at the heart of the current controversy over corporal punishment.


The Supreme Court of India ruled against corporal punishment ten years ago. In doing so, the court upheld a principle adopted by most civilised societies: it is wrong for teachers to beat children. You will not find corporal punishment in most Western European countries or in the United States. It is true that the practice once existed. But as civilisation has moved on, developed societies have been determined to stamp it out.

So why does corporal punishment continue to flourish in India?

In some cases — village schools perhaps — it exists because of primitive facilities and the poor calibre of teachers. But in elite schools, it continues because such schools believe that they can do what they like to our children.

... ... ... ... ...

I hesitate to go much further because I am not in favour of one obvious solution in the La Martiniere case: the involvement of the education ministry. It would be easy to recommend that the government crack down on schools that assault our children. But the truth is that this would be an invitation to petty politicians and mindless bureaucrats to ride rough-shod over independent schools. If there is anything worse than schools preserved in the formaldehyde of colonialism, it is the tyranny of Indian babudom.

So, the only solution is a generic one. The reason schools have so much power over us is because there are so few of them and so many of us in the fast-expanding middle class. Things will never get better till some balance is restored to that equation. When you live in a society where every parent spends sleepless nights over getting his kid into school, it is inevitable that the schools will run riot and treat our kids with contempt.

I am all for education for all and for reaching out to the poorer sections. But let’s not forget that India faces a more immediate crisis. We have a middle class that is growing faster than available educational opportunities. If we do not open more good schools in our cities, then we can steel ourselves for a future where many middle class kids are denied the education they deserve. Or are beaten till they give up and die.

This article was published in the Hindustan Times on Saturday, June 19, 2010. Please read the original article here.
Author :
Tags- Find more articles on - India | schools | Vir Sanghvi

Post your Comments on this Article

Comments will be moderated

More Related Articles
Education for Life
More Articles

An Initiative of
All rights reserved.